MetaRevu
VANGUARD Power Air S2 Paddle

Selkirk

VANGUARD Power Air S2 Paddle

89Universal Acclaim

The Vanguard Power Air S2 is widely praised for its exceptional power, spin, and lightweight design that appeals to aggressive players and those seeking improved mobility at the net. However, the paddle has a notable learning curve with control challenges for some players, and several reviewers report issues with the short handle length and thin profile, which may not suit all hand sizes or preferences.

Sentiment Breakdown

75 positive / 16 neutral / 9 negative

Pros

  • Exceptional power and pop on drives and put-aways
  • Excellent spin generation on serves and returns
  • Lightweight design reduces arm and wrist strain
  • Improved net play speed and maneuverability
  • Rimless/edgeless design reduces mishits

Cons

  • Short handle length uncomfortable for some players
  • Steep learning curve; control challenges for dinking and soft shots
  • Thin paddle profile feels fragile to some reviewers

What Reviewers Mention

Power
32% of reviews
Control
25% of reviews
Spin
20% of reviews
Weight & Maneuverability
14% of reviews
Handle Length
9% of reviews

Specifications

Weight8.1 oz
Surface MaterialCarbon Fiber
Core MaterialPolymer
ShapeHybrid

Where to Buy

Most Recent Reviews: Showing 50 of 88 reviews

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Defensive paddle: Paddle has great spin and control for unparalleled defense. I like it for inside out swings on offense.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Bang!: My favorite paddle, this is my 3rd! I love the shape and short handle.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

Control paddle didn’t work for my wife, not ready: Vanguard not what my wife wants, thought it would better

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Great consistent paddle: I love this paddle! Lots of power. I purchased the one with a very short grip so it took some getting used to but I love it now.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

Great Paddle but I will keep searching: It was a very nice paddle, but the handle was too short. Also felt it was a little too thin.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Right where I’m supposed to be.: I’m an 3.5 player and I’ve really enjoyed the Selkirk VANGUARD Power Air S2. It has great pop on drives and put-aways, and the spin is noticeable right away. It leans toward power, but once I adjusted, I still felt confident with control at the net. Overall, it’s been a fun paddle that’s helped me play more aggressive. Definitely happy with it.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Great Pickle Ball Paddle: This is a very well-made Paddle. I look forward to numerous games played with it! I would recommend it to others.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

Selkirk VANGUARD Power Air - S2: I have the Halo, which I wore out, The S2 Vanguard Control, which I love, Ben Johns Joola, Meh, Not so much for the price, And a CRBN tru-foam which I got for half price, but it's just ok. The S2 Vanguard Power has no power compared to the paddles I mentioned. I thought I would try an Edgeless paddle. Its a 'No' for me. It just felt dead but it had more control i kind felt. I was looking for that "This is the one" paddle because I like the short handle since I d

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Lighter and faster: Faster at the net. I lost some power from the back. Maybe it will be better once I am used to the paddle.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Selkirk Vanguard Power Air - S2 Paddle: I was surprised how much better my game is with this paddle. At first I kept hitting long shots until I got a sense of the sweet spot and the spring. Then I had some great power shots and some easy dink shots that used to be harder to place. The grip is a little short for my hand but it didn't take much for me to adjust and make some good returns.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Lots of power and grip: This paddle has a lot of grip. I am still getting used to it, but it I like it. If you like putting a lot of spin on the ball, this paddle it is a great choice.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

20Generally Unfavorable

Vanguard power air pro: This was not the paddle for me, I don't like the lack of control over my shots , every one told me not to play with it anymore, I sold it to another player and they didn't like it either. I much prefer Lux control Epic or S2 .

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Great purchase - could use more power: Generally very happy with the paddle. Wish there was a faster pace on the shots

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Vanguard Power Air S2: I like the weight and the grip. I think I’m playing better because I’m focusing more due to new paddle.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Happy hand Paddle: very smooth control and handle spin power overall its great!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

40Generally Unfavorable

Ping pong anyone?: It’s so thin and seems fragile. Appreciate the lightness, but it’s a glorified ping pong paddle and I’m not getting any noticeable power out of this “power” paddle. I’ve already reverted back to my control paddle. Bummed. Wish I knew the boom was coming out and this paddle would be a dud, because I would have saved my money and got an actual power paddle. Disappointed :(

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Short grip allows Racquetball wrist curl backhand: Turns serving into "pitching." Great spin/control and great touch! Best Selkirk paddle ever!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

It's not the paddle it's the player: Not in love with it. I purchased an elongated paddle with a shorter grip. The paddle came with the shorter grip (yea!) but is in no way elongated. I will continue to use it from time to time in an effort to adjust. My partners have told me I hit the ball a lot harder with it.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

Expected better: I expected much better but disappointed with how it handled.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Paddle Review: wish it was thicker. Kinda learned paddle thickness thru this purchase

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Great paddle: It is very light and great for an older player. It’s helped me place the ball better and has a big soft spot. I love it 😍

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Nice Power: Moving from a Control Air to a Power Air took a little bit to get use to. I found myself hitting many of my shots long. Once I adjusted all seems to be going well.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

My new paddle: [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Great paddle still getting used to playing with it.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Love Power Air S2: Have been using this paddle for several weeks. Loving it so far. Good power and control!!!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Selkirk Vanguard Power Air S2: The paddle sounds broken when I hit the ball. Many times the ball does jump off the paddle but makes a weird sound compared to all the paddles in the gym. I like the control on third shot drops. I added tungsten weights and it helped my control. It is nice and light for paddle quickness at the net.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Selkirk VANGUARD Power Air - S2 - Pickleball Paddle: This is the second Selkirk vanguard paddle. My first was the Invikta version of the Vanguard Power Air that did work for me even though I tried very hard to get used to it. Silkirk has been very gracious to allow my to exchange the paddle for the S2 version. I noticed from the very first three hits I made with the S2 paddle that it was going to be just right. It feels balanced in my hand, it provides good power that is well controllable and p

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Love my new paddle: Quite powerful but little difficult to control. Love the enhanced spin.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Love It: Love it. After research I found out about this paddle is the best one for me.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

power air s2: have been playing with this paddle for 2 years and have not found another paddle I like better. so I purchased a new paddle same model.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Great paddle: Great paddle as it’s enabled me to drastically increase the spin I put on the ball. It’s accomplished this without sacrificing any power so I’m happy with the versatility of this paddle

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

This paddle has lots of pop!: I love this paddle now that I have become use to the touch. When I first used it I was immediately impressed with the power and spin action. I had a hard time with the soft play initially. After I used it 3 times, I got use to the pop the paddle has and I was able to make those soft touch plays I was used to making. I love the look and feel of this paddle.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Power and Control!: A little extra power and plenty of spin and control - excellent paddle!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Vanguard Power Air - S2: I just received this paddle and have only played with it two times so far. I notice the increase in pace on the ball compared to my original Selkirk paddle (Vanguard 2.0 S2). I'm still getting used to this new paddle, but so far I like the control and increase power. Very satisfied.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Pretty good but pricey: I am a low intermediate player, so maybe this is an overkill for me. I like it that it allows me to do a certain amount of spin which I like (coming from table tennis).

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Selkirk review: Nice feel and control with enough pop when you need it!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Great pickleball paddle: I could feel the difference right away. The power and spin are next level.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

new paddle: It's like driving a Porsche. Quick, handles curves well, spicy. Takes some getting use to. But I am hopeful.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

I was so surprised when the box cam and the packaging was so amazing! Love my new paddle!: It’s really fits my hand so well and the control is great!!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Vanguard: Better than expected, I highly recommend this paddle better control , more power, and better spin . It’s worth the extra money.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Selkirk Vanguard Power Air S2 Paddle: I really love this paddle as it's helped increase the level of my play. It has more power than my first Vanguard S2 paddle and still has the level of control that's required when hitting at a higher level. It feels great in my hand and is helping my game tremendously.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Love the new paddle: First, let me state how much I appreciate the easy return service on the first paddle I purchased. Though a nice paddle, it did not provide enough power for the type of game in which I am typically involved. The exchange for the Vanguard Power Air was seamless, and I am delighted with the new paddle. Selkirk has a new customer for future purchases.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

Not for me: I am a left-handed player, and I am missing a portion of three of my fingers on that hand. I am not sure why, but playing with this paddle has made my hand, very uncomfortable and What is left up my index finger tips split lightly. I am returning the battle and will be ordering an S2 Vanguard 2.0. Thanks.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

20Generally Unfavorable

exchange: it plays tooo fasts not enough control would like to return it and exchange for a different paddle

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

So far so good: I upgraded from the Onix Z5. This feels similar in terms of weight but is less "poppy" than the Z5 which is what I was looking for. Power is similar and spin is also more. I'm not confident how long the spin will last though because it feels like the grittiness is already getting smoothed out the more I play.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Power Air S2: Still getting used to this paddle -- I couldn't seem to get the hang of it the first time last week, but this week worked out much better. I'm used to playing with a paddle that seemed to have plenty of power, so it's taken a while to get used to the added spin that this new one puts on the ball. Put aways at net seem to be MUCH more reliable, and a lot more of my deep drives now seem to be staying in thanks to more top spin generation. After only two times, I can already tell t

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Review: Love it power control all great only slight issue the sound of the pop is a little diff than the other paddles I used and what most people use

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

100Universal Acclaim

Love my new paddle!: I have been a loyal Selkirk user since I started playing in 2021. I have the S2, S2 Vanguard and now the S2 Vanguard Power Air. By far the S2 Vanguard Power Air is my favorite. It provides me control when I need it and power that surprises my opponents. It’s a versatile paddle that WILL improve your game! Thank you Selkirk for continuing to improve and support Pickleball!

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

60Mixed or Average

Disappointed: I was looking for more power and hence returned the Luxx for this one. Not enough power and the sweet spot is very small. Both contrary to what this paddle is supposed to be.

Dick's Sporting Goods logo

Dick's Sporting Goods

verified_purchaser source

80Universal Acclaim

Happy so far: I haven't got to use it enough to form a strong opinion but I can definitely tell the difference from my old beginners paddle. Its weighted nicely and it has a nice sweet spot. I tried my granddaughters Invikta and kind of wish I had purchased that one instead but to be fair I need to give this one a chance to bond with me. ha.

Pickleball Central logo

Pickleball Central

user_generated source

100Universal Acclaim

Selkirk power air: Fabulous racket

Similar Paddles You Might Like

1 of 4 selected

  • VANGUARD Power Air S2 Paddle